Childminder, Nanny, or Daycare: Which Is Right for Your Family?

May 14, 2024 | 8 min. read
Childminder, Nanny, or Daycare: Which Is Right for Your Family?

Deciding on the best childcare for your family is no small feat. You may be considering a Childminder, a Nanny, or a Daycare. But which is the right choice? Inna Circle is here to help you figure that out with this detailed comparison of all three options.

Every family is unique, and so are their needs when it comes to childcare. Cost, flexibility, location, and your child’s individual needs are all crucial factors in this decision. It’s key to understand what each choice—Childminder, Nanny, and Daycare—brings to the table.

In this guide, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each option. We’ll provide practical insights to help you make an informed decision, whether you’re a first-time parent or thinking about changing your current childcare setup. Read on to find the best fit for your family.

Nanny vs. Daycare: How To Decide

A nanny is a professional caregiver who looks after your children in your own home. This personalized, one-on-one care can be invaluable, especially for families with very young children, children with special needs, or children who simply thrive best in a familiar environment.

The most significant advantage of hiring a nanny is the tailored care they provide. They can adapt to your child’s routine, dietary needs, and preferences more easily than a daycare could. Plus, they can also help with light household chores related to the child, such as cleaning up after playtime or doing the child’s laundry.

However, hiring a nanny can often be more expensive than daycare, and it involves becoming an employer with responsibilities like handling payroll and taxes. Furthermore, you’ll need to have a backup plan for times when the nanny is sick or on vacation.

When deciding between a nanny and daycare, it’s essential to consider your child’s personality, needs, and comfort level. Some children might prefer the bustling, social environment of a daycare, while others might feel more comfortable receiving care in their own homes.

Practical considerations such as your budget, work schedule, and the availability of quality daycare centers or nannies in your area should also be factored into your decision. Remember, the best choice is the one that feels right for your family and supports your child’s growth and development in the best possible way.

Day Care Center

A daycare center is a facility that provides care and educational activities for children during the day. Daycares cater to a wide age range, from infants to preschoolers, and sometimes even school-age children. They offer a structured environment, with scheduled activities, meals, and nap times.

Day Care Pros and Cons

Daycare centers have several benefits. They offer a structured routine, which can help children develop a sense of security and order. Daycares also provide plenty of opportunities for social interaction, which is crucial for a child’s social development. 

However, on the downside, children in daycare are more exposed to illnesses due to the number of kids they interact with. Also, daycares operate on a fixed schedule, which might not be flexible enough for some families.

Individual Care

In a daycare setting, individual care might not be as personalized as with a nanny or childminder. However, many daycares maintain low child-to-caregiver ratios to ensure each child gets adequate attention. The caregivers at daycare are trained professionals who can handle different situations and meet the varying needs of multiple children.

Cost and Budget 

The cost of daycare in the Philippines varies widely based on factors like location, services offered, and the age of the child. On average, you can expect to pay between PHP 3,000 to PHP 15,000 per month. 

It’s important to budget for this expense and consider it alongside the benefits a daycare center offers when making your decision.

Hiring a Nanny 

Enlisting the services of a nanny can be an excellent option for families seeking personalized, at-home care for their children. A nanny offers a unique blend of flexibility and familiarity that can make your child feel comfortable while also fitting into your family’s schedule.

Nanny Pros and Cons

Pros: Nannies provide one-on-one attention to your child, allowing for personalized care tailored to your child’s needs. They offer flexibility with their schedules, which can be particularly beneficial for parents with irregular work hours. Also, having a nanny means your child can stay at home, eliminating the need for daily commuting to a daycare center.

Cons: Hiring a nanny can be more expensive than other childcare options. As an employer, you’re responsible for handling their payroll and benefits. If the nanny falls sick or needs time off, you’ll need a backup plan.

Individual Care

A significant advantage of hiring a nanny is the individualized care they can provide. This one-on-one attention can be especially beneficial for children who thrive in quieter environments or require specialized care. 

The nanny can adapt to your child’s routines, preferences, and needs, making for a highly personalized childcare experience.

Cost and Budget

The cost of hiring a nanny in the Philippines can vary significantly depending on factors such as the nanny’s experience level, the number of children to be cared for, and the specific duties the nanny will perform. 

On average, the monthly salary for a full-time nanny in the Philippines ranges from PHP 8,000 to PHP 15,000. Remember, as an employer, you’re also responsible for mandatory benefits under Philippine law.

Hiring a Childminder

Choosing a childminder can be a superb option for families that value a home-like environment but also appreciate the structure that a small group setting can provide. Childminders often care for a few different children at once, offering more socialization opportunities than a nanny but in a more intimate setting than a daycare.

Childminder Pros and Cons


Childminders provide a home-like environment with more opportunities for social interaction compared to a nanny. They often care for children of different ages, allowing your child to interact with both older and younger peers. This setup can also be less expensive than hiring a nanny.


Childminders typically have fixed hours, which might not be flexible enough for some families. As with daycare centers, your child may be more exposed to common childhood illnesses due to interaction with more children.

Individual Care

Childminders can offer a good balance between individual care and group interaction. While your child won’t receive one-on-one attention as they would with a nanny, the small group setting allows the childminder to cater to each child’s individual needs while promoting social skills through interaction with other children.

Cost and Budget

The cost of hiring a childminder in the Philippines is generally lower than the cost of a nanny. However, prices can vary widely depending on factors such as location, the childminder’s qualifications, and the number of children they’re caring for. 

On average, you can expect to pay between PHP 5,000 and PHP 10,000 per month for a childminder in the Philippines.

Nanny vs. daycare vs childminder cost comparison

Selecting the right child care option is more than just about the environment and services offered; it’s also about affordability. The cost of child care varies significantly depending on whether you choose a nanny, daycare, or childminder. Let’s delve into the financial implications of each option.

A nanny is generally the most expensive childcare option. Nannies are paid an hourly rate, which can add up quickly, especially for full-time care. In addition to their salary, you’d be responsible for their benefits, taxes, and potentially even room and board if you choose a live-in nanny.

In contrast, a daycare center charges a flat fee that often includes meals, educational activities, and care during standard working hours. However, extra costs may arise for extended hours, late pick-ups, field trips, and more. Also, prices can vary significantly based on location, with urban areas typically charging more than rural ones.

Lastly, a childminder usually falls somewhere between a nanny and daycare in terms of cost. Like daycare centers, childminders often charge a flat weekly or monthly fee, but because they take care of fewer children, they can offer more personalized attention without the high cost of a nanny.

Choosing the best child care for your baby

When it comes to choosing the best child care for your baby, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The decision will depend on your family’s unique needs, circumstances, and preferences. Here are some factors to consider:

Your Child’s Personality and Needs

Some children thrive in social settings with lots of activities and peers, making daycare or a childminder a great option. Others may prefer a quieter, more familiar environment, which a nanny can provide.

Your Schedule

If you work irregular hours, a nanny might be the best option as they offer the most flexibility. On the other hand, daycare centers and childminders usually operate on fixed schedules, which could work well for parents with standard working hours.


As discussed above, nannies are typically the most expensive option, followed by childminders and then daycare centers. It’s important to consider what you can realistically afford without straining your budget.

Quality of Care

Regardless of the type of care you choose, it’s crucial to ensure that your child will be in a safe, nurturing environment where they can learn and grow.

Need Help Hiring Childminders in the Philippines? Let Inna Circle Guide You!

Are you ready to take the first step towards finding the perfect child care solution for your family? Are you considering hiring childminders, but feel overwhelmed by the process? At Inna Circle, we’re here to help. 

We specialize in connecting families with top-quality childminders in the Philippines that meet our rigorous standards.

We understand that every family has unique childcare needs, and we’re dedicated to helping you navigate these important decisions. With our comprehensive childcare services, you can rest easy knowing we’ve done the legwork to ensure you have access to the best possible care options.

Curious about childminder fees? We’ve got you covered. Our platform provides transparent information about costs, so you can plan your budget accurately and confidently.

Don’t navigate this journey alone – join the Inna Circle community today. Let us guide you in hiring childminders and other childcare professionals who can provide the best care for your precious little one. Join Inna Circle Now!

Be Updated

Be the first to know about our newest offerings or promotions!